Martin P Wilson


Ideas, Innovation, Inspiration, Insight, IT

Facilitation and Mentoring for Success.

Ill_Fares_the_Land_by_Tony_JudtSociety is ill and needs more than capitalism or socialism to create fairness and happiness. Tony Judt challenges current ideas on society and government.

Tony Judt is currently Professor and Director of the Remarque Institute at New York University. He is a highly honoured author and editor of thirteen books and a renowned thinker with an international reputation.

Ill Fares the Land – New Challenges for Society and Governance

Ill Fares the Land is A Treatise on Our Present Discontents in which Tony Judt argues that the questions and associated lessons that long used to define politics are being forgotten. As a result there is growth of inequality in the UK and USA and he raises the questions of whether is desirable, prudent or even supportable.

Socially Concerned but Apolitical Challenge to Current Thinking

A reader with leanings to the political right may initially be put off by the apparent socialist arguments at the start of the book. However such readers should bear with Judt as the left and right wing attitudes and failures are addressed in equal measure. Although Ill Fares the Land is not party political it does address the nature of society and fairness that have engaged political thinking since the philosophers of classical Greece.

Ill Fares the Land argues that the basic questions still apply and are no longer being asked. Instead society, government and politics are locked into a fixed and partisan way of thinking. Judt challenges the reader to go back to the basic questions and test how society and its undoubted needs could be better served.

In Ill Fares the Land Tony Judt shows how all political and economic models are failing people and society. He challenges the reader to think afresh about the nature of society and what it means as a whole and to the individual.

Fresh Thinking on Society From a Small but Important Book

In just six chapters with an introduction and conclusion Professor Judt makes a strong case for rethinking the nature of society and its governance. The Introduction takes the form of “Guide for the Perplexed” and is followed by the six chapters:The Way We Live Now

  • The World We Have Lost
  • The Unbearable Lightness of Politics
  • Goodbye to All That?
  • What is to Be Done?
  • The Shape of Things to Come

The conclusion pulls it all together and asks “What is Dead in Social Democracy” and the book as a whole raises more questions than it answers. Ill Fares the Land is not a prescriptive book but a description of where democracy has got to and how it is failing to satisfy the needs of society and individuals. More work needs to be done by the reader and others to answer the hugely important questions posed.

A Short Book That Needs Careful Reading

If it were not for the typography Ill Fares the Land would be a slim volume. Whilst not a difficult read the ideas are complex and important so bear careful consideration. For students of political and moral philosophy this is one of several recent books on the subject that question current thinking particularly on equality, fairness, justice and an individual dissatisfaction or the sense that something is missing . It may be signs of change in the wind.

The title Ill Fares the Land is from the Oliver Goldmsith’s 1770 poem The Deserted Village. There are many quotations from political philosophers, economic thinkers with literary allusions throughout.

Ill Fares the Land, A Treatise on Our Present Discontents (2010, ISBN: 978-1-846-14359-5) is published in hardback by Allen Lane, a Penguin imprint, at £20.


First appeared on Suite101

Add your comment

Your name:
Your email:

Quick Thoughts

Has Military Action Ever Dissuaded Tyrants?

Syria - flagIn his speech before the war in Iraq Tony Blair, the UK Prime Minister, argued that not intervening would send a message that tyrants would feel at liberty to act without consequence. By military action in Iraq, he argued, those who would perpetrate atrocities would think twice. There would not seem to be any evidence, before or since, that would back up that contention.

We now have David Cameron, the current Prime Minister, making essentially the same arguments – do politicians ever learn from history?


Government Spending is not Driver of Growth

Parliament Square London IC02001If more public spending is the only way to create growth then surely governments have become too large a part of the economy? Government is about spending and has little to do with creating wealth.

The best government can do is move wealth from individuals and business to those who serve government.


Capped Bonuses, There May be Trouble Ahead

Politicians do not seem to be good at imagining unintended consequences. The cap on bankers’ bonuses, however popular, may be counter-productive in reducing risk.

Dark Stormy Skys and Beauty Often CoexistIf a smaller proportion of a trader’s income is at risk if a trade goes wrong they may pursue high-risk opportunities to get that big win. If it works they guarantee the full bonus and could also use it to negotiate a higher salary (and bonus) for the following year. If it fails the downside is limited by the capped bonus to a smaller part of overall income. At the end of the day traders are competitive and gamblers at heart so will they be more likely to pursue the big win when their own risk is limited?

Copyright © 1995-2010 Solidus Ltd & M-dash.

All Rights Reserved.Copyright Explained.